The Gunnison Valley is home to some of the most sought-after trout species in the West, but two stand out: the brown trout and the rainbow trout. While they often share the same water, these two fish have distinct behaviors, preferences, and feeding habits. Understanding the difference is key to having a successful day on the river. As guides, we spend our seasons studying these fish, and here’s a breakdown of how to target each one.
Meet the Contenders: Brown vs. Rainbow
Brown Trout (Salmo trutta): The brown trout is the wily, old resident of the river. Known for their intelligence and elusive nature, browns are often considered the ultimate prize. They are identified by their golden-brown flanks and a pattern of dark spots, often mixed with red or orange spots circled by light halos. Browns are structure-oriented and can be highly territorial, especially larger, mature fish.
Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): Rainbows are the river’s athletes. Famous for their acrobatic leaps and hard fights, they bring an undeniable excitement to any catch. You can identify them by their iconic pinkish-red stripe running down their sides and the numerous black spots covering their body and fins. Rainbows are often more opportunistic and can be found feeding actively in faster currents.
When to Target Each Species
Your success often depends on the season, as each species becomes more active at different times of the year.
- Spring: As the water warms and insect activity picks up, rainbows become very active. They move into riffles and seams to feed heavily after a long winter. This is a prime time for nymphing and occasional dry fly action.
- Summer: Both species feed aggressively. Rainbows will readily take dry flies during hatches, while big browns often feed during lower light periods, like early morning and late evening.
- Fall: This is the season for big, aggressive brown trout. As they prepare to spawn, browns become territorial and will violently strike at large streamer patterns swung through their territory. Rainbows will often trail behind them, feeding on dislodged eggs.
Where to Find Them: Reading the Water
Knowing where each species prefers to hold will dramatically increase your chances of a hook-up.
- Brown Trout Habitat: Look for structure. Browns love the safety of undercut banks, submerged logs, deep pools, and shady spots. They prefer slower currents where they can ambush prey without expending too much energy. Think deep, dark, and protected.
- Rainbow Trout Habitat: Rainbows are often found in more open water. Look for them in faster currents, like riffles and the main seams of a run, where food is consistently delivered to them. They also suspend in the middle of the water column more frequently than browns.
Tactics for Targeting Each Species
Tailoring your approach is critical. A strategy that works for a rainbow may not tempt a wary brown trout.
- For Aggressive Browns: Streamers are the go-to tactic, especially in the fall. A large, articulated streamer ripped past an undercut bank or through a deep pool can trigger a predatory strike. Patience is key; you are hunting for one or two big fish.
- For Opportunistic Rainbows: Rainbows are often willing to eat a well-presented nymph or dry fly. A dry-dropper rig is a fantastic way to cover water, allowing you to target fish feeding on the surface and subsurface simultaneously. Nymphing through faster riffles and seams is also highly effective.
Whether you’re hoping to entice a trophy brown from its hiding spot or enjoy the high-energy fight of a rainbow, the Gunnison River offers endless opportunities.
Ready for a Fun Filled Day on the Water? Book Your Trip Today.